In the work of Jennifer Llewellyn (2012), a restorative approach is, foremost, a way of looking at the world that understands human selves as arising in and through relationships. As such, this worldview holds that individual wellbeing is inextricable from the health of the relational ecosystems (which include personal, social, and institutional relationships) to which an individual belongs. A restorative approach to the world is centrally concerned with what is required from human agents throughout a given relational ecosystem to secure and sustain just relations, which is to say, relationships in which “each person’s rights to equal dignity, concern and respect are satisfied” and each person can, therefore, be well and flourish (Llewellyn 2012, 1).
-
Professor Jennifer Llewellyn (2012) has developed what she calls a ‘restorative approach’ drawing on feminist relational theory that posits that human selves emerge in and through relationships. A way of thinking about the world and human relationships, a restorative approach departs from liberal, individualistic conceptions of the self, instead, viewing human selves as nodes within networks of interpersonal, social, and institutional relationships. While a restorative approach understands humans as having agency–“our choices and actions are not dictated wholly by the sum of our relationships” (Llewellyn 2012, 294)–it insists that we “cannot make or realize our choices by ourselves and our choices have implications for others” (ibid). A restorative approach has crucial implications for thinking about selfhood, communities, workplaces, institutions, organisations, societies, systems, personal relationships, conflict, harm, and justice on various scales.
Llewellyn’s theorization and practice of a restorative approach are preoccupied with a desire to understand the circumstances and conditions that make the related concepts of relational wellbeing, flourishing, and justice possible within a given relational ecology. Llewellyn defines relational justice (which is needed for relational wellbeing and flourishing) as mutuality of respect, concern, and dignity (2011). The mobilization of a restorative approach within a given relational ecology is decidedly not about trying to “restore” or “repair” relationships that have been harmed by returning to a past order of things. As Llewellyn (2012) writes, “grounding restorative justice in relational theory helps to address one of the most common misconceptions of restorative justice – that it is aimed at repairing existing relationships or seeks a return to the way things were prior to a specific harmful action or incident” (383). Instead, mobilizing a restorative approach is proactive, future-oriented work in which one asks, What is required from whom across this relational ecology to establish or re-establish just relations, which is to say, for people to be well and flourish? And what day-to-day conditions and commitments are required to ensure that this support can be offered?
While the usefulness of a restorative approach for fostering relational justice and wellbeing is not confined to problem-solving, it can be used to solve problems when there has been a breach in the mutuality of respect, concern, or dignity within a given relational system. In these cases, a restorative approach emphasizes the importance of meaningful accountability, but it is less concerned with blame and punishment. Indeed, if a restorative approach maintains that, despite having agency, we “cannot make or realize our choices [fully] by ourselves” because of the relational nature of selfhood, it follows that responsibility and accountability are (at least somewhat) distributed across the network of relationships within which any one individual exists. A restorative approach to problem-solving involves identifying, analyzing, understanding, and addressing the relational circumstances and conditions that created the fertile ground in which a problem could arise. This work requires designing processes for gathering relevant information across the relational ecology at hand to conduct a thorough relational analysis and create a plan for moving forward. Because a restorative approach is concerned with relational justice across the entire ecology in which a problem arises, when designing solutions to a problem, a restorative approach takes careful measures to avoid worsening the mutuality of respect, concern, and dignity anywhere within the ecology at large. Ultimately, a successful relational response to a breach in just relations within a relational system, be it an institution, family, or workplace, “deepens the relational literacy of the culture through developing the social and emotional intelligence within the institution [or other relational system]” (2018, 352-353).
-
Downie, Jocelyn, and Jennifer J. Llewellyn. 2018. “Relational Theory and Health Law and Policy.” Health Law Journal (Special Edition). 193-210.
Llewellyn, Jennifer J. 2012. “Integrating Peace, Justice and Development in a Relational Approach to Peacebuilding.” Ethics and Social Welfare 6 (3): 290–302. doi:10.1080/17496535.2012.704386.
Llewellyn, Jennifer J. 2011. “Restorative Justice: Thinking Relationally about Justice.” In Being Relational: Reflections on Relational Theory and Health Law and Policy, edited by Jennifer J. Llewellyn and Jocelyn Downie. UBC Press. 89–108.