Named after wise practices, wise research infrastructures are the socio-technical systems, mechanisms, and technologies we develop or adapt in order to keep our practices wise, i.e., embracing a relational worldview, supporting inventive knowledge, helping to instantiate our guiding principles, and facilitating collective and responsive discernment and implementation of the values and methods that frame our work.
-
Named after wise practices, wise research infrastructures are the socio-technical systems, mechanisms, and technologies we develop or adapt in order to keep our practices wise, i.e., embracing a relational worldview, supporting inventive knowledge, helping to instantiate our guiding principles, and facilitating collective and responsive discernment and implementation of the values and methods that frame our work.
Infrastructures, in the words of Carla Rice, are the “containers and connectors” (Rice, et. al 3) that allow matter, or the things that matter, to move and be exchanged. According to LaDuke and Cowen, “infrastructure is how sociality extends itself; it is how life is provisioned or curtailed. In its most immediate material and graspable forms, infrastructure underpins and enacts sustenance and reproduction” (22). Normally, infrastructures obfuscate their presence and operation, fading into the background of everyday life. Their presence is typically only experienced in the moments where they fail. Consider, for instance, sewage pipes, electrical wires, or radio spectra. Because of their nature as hidden conduits, Rice argues that infrastructures can insidiously and asymmetrically enact “decisions about the provisioning of life-sustaining resources to various constituencies" (Rice et. al 9).
Wise research infrastructures are different because of the following characteristics:
Containment: Rather than circumscribe, simplify, and stabilize problems only to fail when confronted with relational excess, wise infrastructures aim at containment. Wise infrastructures seek a methodological accounting for the diversity of values, principles, and ethical imperatives that motivate them. For wise research infrastructures, when the infrastructure “leaks,” it’s not a failure, but an invitation to revise, adapt, and think ethically about how a problem is being framed.
Reflexivity: Rather than “understand, then solve” (Rittel and Webber 162), wise research infrastructures are self-reflexive and expect for understanding to be an ongoing process that is emergent throughout the research practice itself. A wise research infrastructure takes seriously the OFIFC’s invitation to ask “Are we doing the right thing?”, which has been a guiding principle for SBF/MSMA (see Compass Tool).
Presentation: Rather than fade into the background, wise research infrastructures announce their presence and operation. Wise research infrastructures do not presume to rest on settled knowledge, but are invested in opening themselves to critique, adaptation, and reiteration and in making their utility understood. Moreover, by making themselves visible in this way, wise research infrastructures also reveal the labour that goes into their co-creation.
Flexibility: Rather than activate best practices and toolkits, wise research infrastructures promote methods to engage with inventive knowledge. Because the conditions that affect our work are always shifting, just as our understanding of those conditions also shifts, wise research infrastructures are interested in co-generating embodied and relational know-how. To that end, they need to be revisable so that they can adapt and respond to changes in the conditions, values, and needs of participant-researchers.
Movement: While most research is interested in transmitting knowledge, wise research infrastructures are interested in making the flow of knowledge multi-directional. Not only do the outcomes of research need to be shared externally, but sharing the processes, practices, tools, insights, challenges, and failures of the work are indispensable not only to, yes, future scholars interested in doing similar work, but they are of vital importance to the internal research practice. The way we can come to understand in what ways our work is locally-appropriate, or how it can be changed to be so.
-
LaDuke, Winona and Deborah Cowen. 2020. “Beyond Wiindigo Infrastructure.” The South Atlantic Quarterly 199(2): 243-68. https://doi.org/10.1215/00382876-8177747.
Rice, Carla et al. 2025. “Intersectionality Meets Infrastructure: Recruitment Matrices and Identity Overflow in Just Research.” Qualitative Inquiry 0(0): 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1177/10778004251337413.
Rittel, Horst and Webber, Melvin. 1973. “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning.” Policy Sciences 4(2): 155-69. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730.
-
Jeff Gagnon (author)
Alice Hinchliffe (reviewer)
Nicole Nolette (reviewer)